In his first days as prime minister, Andy Burnham presented his amuse-bouches to the British public. He announced that VAT, a consumption tax, would be cut on electricity bills from 5% to 0% from October. The cap on most bus fares would be slashed from £3 ($4) to £2 for all of 2027. From April, pubs and clubs in England will get a 20% business-rate cut. Mr Burnham’s portion sizes are meagre: the electricity tax cut will save just £25 per household in this tax year, according to the Institute for Fiscal Studies, a think-tank.
These tasters show Mr Burnham’s strengths. He is a more political animal than Sir Keir Starmer, his predecessor, and understands that tackling the cost of living will be crucial for his success. Unfortunately, he has served up policies that resemble baked Camemberts: they have lots of fatty calories and are liable to cause indigestion later on.
The calorie count is large and growing. Cutting electricity bills costs £850m this tax year alone. Mr Burnham says he will fund it by scrapping Sir Keir’s scheme to introduce digital IDs. But that policy was unfunded, so in reality he will need to find the cash elsewhere. It will be hard to ransack energy budgets, as he has already raided them for £454m to help fund the bus-fare cuts. These early decisions reflect Mr Burnham’s big-spending instincts. If he is not careful, the state’s waistline could balloon.
Nor are Mr Burnham’s offerings nutritious. By capping bus fares nationally, he is taking away the agency of mayors to decide how to support their bus networks. That’s the opposite of the devolution dream he ostensibly espouses. He is also blunting price signals.
The electricity tax cut is poorly targeted: richer households will save the most money. And the scrapped digital-ID scheme would in time have made it much easier to use public services. These are ominous signs of a short-termist leader ducking hard decisions.
Mr Burnham says these moves show his promise to “bring back hope”. But the most disgruntled diner is one who gets excited by the menu but disappointed by the food. The best way to tackle the cost of living is to get real wages rising through growth. If Mr Burnham is distracted by £25 giveaways, not even his communication skills will save him.

