Revolution is in the air. You can’t throw a rock at a Westminster summer party—and come the speeches it is tempting—without hitting a 28-year-old with a PDF on how to reinvent the British state. Almost everyone agrees: the government, in its current form, does not work. Andy Burnham, the incoming prime minister, declares “Whitehall culture” to be the root of many of Britain’s problems. Reform UK, his populist-right rival, wants to replace the top ranks of the professional civil service with political appointees.
But what if the state could be improved through fixes that are prosaic, and often have been kicked around for years? Although such an approach would not remedy everything, it could be a start. Call it the low-hanging-fruit school of government.
Far from being in decline, the British state is perfectly capable of serving voters well, if only it were subject to “some pretty basic management practices”, reckons Darren Jones, the chief secretary to the prime minister. He found that even getting hold of a departmental organisation chart beneath the most senior staff was a struggle. “Like, who do I employ here?” he says. “It just didn’t exist.”
Mr Jones’s job was created last September in an attempt to regain momentum for Sir Keir Starmer’s stalling government. Like his predecessors, the prime minister despaired at how slowly Whitehall worked to turn manifesto promises into reality. Some progress was made, but not enough for the Labour Party, which has ousted Sir Keir. Mr Jones will leave his post with him on July 20th.
The fruity prescription for improving how government functions comes down to “pretty simple and obvious” performance management and prioritisation. The pay and prospects of senior civil servants are now determined by their department or unit’s performance against “key performance indicators”, which in turn reflect their ministers’ political priorities. The disquiet of officials who have been ranked “amber/green” rather than “green” suggests it is having the desired behavioural effect, claims Mr Jones. (Some civil servants are sceptical.) The bonus pool is now split among a smaller group of high performers.
Fruit picking is in vogue. Wonks such as Matthew Yglesias and Sam Bowman argue that Britain is remarkably good at hard stuff, such as AI, financial services and commercial law. It struggles at things it mastered in the 19th century—such as building enough housing, energy and transport infrastructure—that could be freed up by Parliament. The obstacles to tax reform, too, are more political than mechanical: all the levers are in the hands of a powerful chancellor.
Antonia Romeo, the cabinet secretary, Britain’s most senior civil servant, has also focused on obvious wins since her appointment in February. Some early initiatives reflect simple decluttering, such as an attempt to cut the number of public consultations the government launches.
Restructuring the centre of government would help. Mr Jones failed to convince his colleagues of the case for a single, powerful office of the prime minister through a merger of Downing Street and the Cabinet Office, an idea that has been around for years, and which Mr Burnham is said to be interested in. Sir Keir’s office is weirdly puny for a G7 economy.
Britain could save billions from misfiring programmes, if only the Treasury held real-time data on how departments use money, Mr Jones reckons. Today spending performance is reported monthly, and often patchily, to a central database called Oscar. It leaves the Treasury “more as a bank than a finance department”, which outsiders find “utterly barmy”. A pilot for better monitoring is under way, but it has rubbed against Whitehall’s fiefs.
And perhaps the public could use public services more easily if they had a single system of digital ID—another Starmer-era programme that, under Mr Burnham, may gather dust. Such tech “is really not very difficult to build: everyone’s got it; other countries use it,” says Mr Jones. Yet in Britain it is treated as a technological gamble and a totalitarian imposition. If Britain excels at anything, it is pretending that low-dangling crops hang far out of reach.

