THE “WOKE”, race-and-gender-focused ideology that peaked in 2020 had no leader, but Nikole Hannah-Jones has a strong claim to be its defining intellectual. A journalist for the New York Times Magazine, she wrote “The 1619 Project”, a revisionist history of America centred on slavery, and won plaudits for a story in 2016 about sending her daughter to a school with mostly poor, non-white pupils. Her latest article, published on September 20th, is a partial mea culpa that has triggered a torrent of anti-woke schadenfreude. It recounts her daughter’s subsequent ordeal of absent or neglectful teachers and rowdy classmates, and rage at the sacrifice of her education in the vain hope of fixing a broken system one child at a time.
Yet even as Ms Hannah-Jones takes personal responsibility for this “betrayal” of her child, she says little about the progressive-backed education policies that arguably contributed to the dysfunction of the schools her daughter attended. Moreover, the main explanation she provides for the schools’ failings is decades out of date.
Ms Hannah-Jones cites a study from 2019 by EdBuild, an advocacy group, reporting that “nationally, schools in predominantly non-white districts receive $23 billion less in annual funding than their heavily white counterparts”. From this she concludes that such schools’ poor test scores merely “reflect” this financial “disadvantage”. She could hardly have picked a worse example to support this claim than her daughter’s own Public School (PS) 307 in New York, which spent $52,349 per pupil in 2024-25, making it one of the best-funded schools in one of America’s highest-spending districts. And PS 307 is no exception, but rather an extreme example of the national pattern: state schools with the lowest shares of white pupils actually receive the most funding.
The belief that poor areas have poorly funded schools is grounded in history. In 1940, 68% of school budgets came from local sources such as property taxes. But a series of redistributive reforms starting in the 1960s supplemented these funds with state dollars and, to a lesser extent, federal money largely allocated to poor districts (and not counted in EdBuild’s study). According to a recent study by the Brookings Institution, a think-tank, the poorest and least-white quintiles of school districts had the greatest per-pupil spending as early as 1976-77. This pattern still held in 2020-21, even after accounting for the higher prevailing wages in heavily non-white districts that tend to be in big cities, and subsequently strengthened thanks to Democrats’ covid-era fiscal-stimulus package. The Economist’s analysis finds that in 2024, the average black pupil’s school district spent 3.5% more per pupil after adjusting for wage differentials than those of their white counterparts. The corresponding premium for Hispanic pupils was 0.9%.
This spending, however, has not yielded equal learning. In national testing of 13-to-14-year-olds in reading and maths in 2024, the average white pupil scored in the 58th percentile, compared with the 32nd for the average black exam-taker. Some of this gap stems from black pupils being more likely to be poor, and therefore more likely to have greater educational needs, which may justify a more progressive funding distribution. Schools like PS 307 often have more children with learning disabilities, and they need more specialists to help pupils with difficult home environments and those who are learning English.
However, education scholars also highlight a host of problems beyond money, most of which are apparent in Ms Hannah-Jones’s account. Unionised teachers are paid largely based on seniority, rather than on performance or on the difficulty of their school environments. As a result, teachers in poor areas tend to flee to schools in richer areas with fewer disciplinary issues, saddling their former schools with a revolving door of inexperienced teachers. Teachers who frequently miss work or whose pupils fare poorly remain in classrooms because they are hard to replace. Promoting children to higher grades despite low scores on standardised tests—which Ms Hannah-Jones has said measure privilege rather than intelligence or school quality—makes pupils unaware that they have failed to master material. And failing to discipline disruptive children or remove them from classrooms impedes all of their classmates’ efforts to learn.
Many of Ms Hannah-Jones’s critics still give her credit for her public reckoning. But the main lesson from her parable is not that every parent with the means to escape such schools should do so. It is to heed the message of the principal of her daughter’s second school: that “lower[ing] expectations” for non-white pupils is “racism under the guise of anti-racism”.

